Free Will in Psychiatry: A Clinical Introduction-View Presentation

Video Transcription

Video Summary

In an extensive discussion on free will related to psychiatry, Wren Belcher and Dr. Aftab explored various perspectives integrating philosophical, psychological, and neuroscientific approaches. Dr. Aftab began by delving into the neuroscience behind free will, highlighting a seminal experiment by Benjamin Libet that indicated brain activity preceding conscious intentions, suggesting a deterministic mechanism in human actions. This spurred a debate involving neuroscientific, philosophical, and methodological inquiries about the realities of conscious decision-making.<br /><br />Key to this exploration was the distinction between different types of free will, with libertarian free will positing an undetermined choice, while compatibilism offers that free will can coexist with determinism. The compatibilist view suggests that decisions emerge from a complex interplay of conscious and unconscious processes, reason responsiveness being a nuanced account of agency in deterministic settings. This perspective aligns with legal understandings of moral responsibility, where the emphasis on practical reason and agency remains intact despite deterministic interpretations.<br /><br />Subsequently, Wren Belcher examined the practical implications of these theories in psychotherapy, arguing that therapy can enhance free will by reducing symptoms and actively changing patients' locus of control. Various psychotherapies like DBT, ACT, and psychoanalysis interpret and utilize concepts of free will differently, yet uniformly underscore the potential for increased personal agency through treatment.<br /><br />The discussion further addressed free will's relevance in forensic psychiatry, particularly concerning legal standards that evaluate a defendant's mental state and control over actions during criminal activities. It noted that legal systems do not necessarily demand a libertarian conception of free will, instead focusing on practical reasoning capacities, paralleling compatibilist insights.<br /><br />Participants engaged in probing questions about the implications of deterministic vs. libertarian perspectives, showcasing the ongoing debates surrounding free will's conceptual and practical roles in psychiatry and law.

Keywords

free will

psychiatry

neuroscience

Benjamin Libet

determinism

libertarian free will

compatibilism

moral responsibility

psychotherapy

forensic psychiatry

DBT

ACT

personal agency